People don’t normally wake up exclaiming how much they want to visit aged care facilities. Usually there is a catalyst; a fall, a spell in hospital or just a slow dawning that your mum or dad is no longer capable of managing on their own at home. And then suddenly, you are bombarded with catalogues, price lists and waiting lists – along with work and children and guilt.
Fact is, the majority of aged care homes “look good” on their websites. The real difference only becomes obvious when you get on the ground, talk to staff and see how the residents are enjoying their day.
This guide is designed to help answer the most important questions you need to know when weighing up aged care homes. It will help you identify the essentials, ask the right questions, trust your instincts and know what it will all cost. It’s an emotional decision and the decision has costs.
Why Proper Comparison of Aged Care Homes is Important
Selecting a residential aged care home is not the same as choosing a motel for a quick holiday. You are not only selecting a home for someone and their loved ones, it is also for their food and entertainment.
The form indicates itself early on. The individual withdraws, the family bickering begins and the second placement may not work out for anyone. A few extra steps can alleviate a great deal of pain down the road.
Most Common Family Mistakes
By far the most common mistake made by families is to choose the most attractive lobby. Fresh paint and a coffee pot tell you nothing about who hears the buzzer at 2:00 AM.
Other common errors include:
– Opting to select a facility based on the location where care is provided without evaluating the quality of care offered.
– Wading through the fee agreement because of exhaustion.
– Only one time per round at the home time.
– Not taking into account the loved one’s wishes.
What to Look for When Comparing Aged Care Homes
It is recommended that you visit no less than two or three homes to be able to have a point of comparison. People should take notes right away after a home is visited to retain details.
Observe How Employees Handle Interactions
The “Attitude of staff” is the most important thing in aged care. A worn out lounge room can be refurbed, but it is much more difficult to change a culture of talking over residents.
Is staff being subtle? Knock before entering a room, bend down to talk to a person in a wheelchair rather than looking down on them from above. Remember residents name and talk to them about their lives, for example are they a football fan or do they take sugar in their tea.
Ask what the staff turnover is. If there are regularly new members of staff, this can be difficult to cope with for someone with dementia. Also ask about the number of agency staff.
Let Your Nose & Eyes Help Out
A newly cleaned showroom can look pristine, but cleanliness should be judged on far more than a showroom appearance.
While the odd mild odour in any care setting is bound to happen, strong smell of urine and overuse of air freshener to mask the smell of stale odors are immediate red flags. It is wise to check the bathrooms, the dining areas and the room corners, not just the front door.
It is also vital to look at the residents. Are they well dressed, with hair and clothes soiled? These are all pointers towards the quality of staff support.
Ask About the Daily Routine
The routine is the vital question. Does the age care home have a routine that is flexible and adaptable, or does everyone need to fit into the routine?
Ask what a normal time to get up, is the time to have lunch or dinner and whether it is out of the question for a football game to be kept watch of by staying awake or for a resident to sleep in. One who has gotten up at that hour for the last eighty years should not be allowed to sleep in till nine o’clock. On the other hand, a bird of the night should not be forced to turn in till seven.
Quality homes accept routines as advice rather than strict regimes.
Taste the Food
The importance of food is never quite as apparent. For some, the food in their lives is only one of the last sources of joy.
Ask about the possibility of remaining for lunch. Is it warm and fresh and really good or is it all bland or unappetizing? Do the residents get a choice? Can the kitchen provide different textures of food or specific dishes without lacking taste?
Next, note if staff support residents who struggle to eat. If your plate is cleared and taken away while you have uneaten food, this may raise some alarm bells.
Check the Medical and Clinical Support
This is an area to probe. Find out if staff are available in the evenings and overnight and if there is always a registered nurse on duty. Ask how often a doctor visits and whether your loved one can keep his or her own doctor.
Ask about the protocols in place for administration of medications, falls and wound care. Find out how a resident is handled if he/she needs to be hospitalized. Are the family members informed right away? Who escorts the resident to the hospital?
Inquire about staff training. If your family member has dementia, Parkinson’s or other special needs, find out what kind of training staff members have. “We cater to everyone” isn’t an answer.
Ignore the Calendar of Events
Although the community may offer an engaging list of activities, the real question is, are residents participating?
Drop in around mid-morning or mid-afternoon. Do residents have friends over? Are they chatting, working in the yard, playing a game of cards or relaxing outside, or are they sitting in front of a turned-off television?
Life is also improved by quality facilities offering activities consistent with a residents real interests. A retired farmer may not join in a craft hour, but he will enjoy working in a vegetable garden.
Get Clear Answers on Price
Talking about money can be awkward when talking about a loved one, but it is a talk that has to happen.
Australian aged care fees might include a daily basic fee, means-tested contributions and an accommodation fee, which you can normally pay in full as a refundable accommodation deposit (RAD), in daily payments, or a combination of the two. As this is affected by the new Aged Care Act starting in late 2025, find out from each facility whether this applies to your circumstances. Then find out about any other costs, including hairdressers, newspapers, premium meals or “additional services” packages.
A good provider won’t dodge the financials – a firm who is not forthcoming should be a red flag. If you feel the home is beginning to ‘skirt around’ the issue and you’re being pushed to sign under pressure, take a step back, put everything in writing and seek advice from an aged care financial adviser – it’s a good investment.
Area, Vibe, and Sense of Home
Location Matters, but Not Most
Have family nearby, so visitors are more likely. This can be a big plus for the residents. However, a good quality facility twenty five minutes away is better than a below-average one in close proximity.
Think about who will be coming most often and the best way for them to arrive. Think about parking, public transportation, and visiting times.
Go With the Emotional Feel
Sometimes it is like walking into a room where you get the “warm” feeling; while in some places it is completely opposite and there is a cold, clinical feeling. Never underestimate those feelings: the residents do not.
Regional families when weighing up options are often told that things like Finlay Regional Care stood out because it felt like it was part of the community and not a facility. In fact, emotional reactions like this warrant deep consideration, regardless of what area is being assessed.
Ask How They Communicate with Families
Ask how the facility will keep in touch with the family. Will someone let you know if a person falls or if his or her health status changes? Are meetings scheduled to plan care? Who do you call if you are concerned and how long does it take for an answer?
Furthermore, inquire if there is any process for receiving complaints. Any center will have complaints at some point, but what matters is if they actually take them on board and respond to them.
Some rapid answers to questions
How many homes should I visit? If it is manageable, visit at least three homes. And, if possible, visit the best home two times, one of those visits being unannounced.
Will the parent attend the tours? If possible, the parent should attend. It will be their future home and their well-being is more important than anyone else’s opinion!
What if the choice is wrong? You can leave if you choose to. This is not the best of course, but you are not there for ever.
Making the Call
Choosing an aged care home is a difficult decision, and there are rarely clear-cut decisions. The essentials include good, loving and skilled staff, affordable prices, good food, proper health care, and a place where you can retain the dignity of your loved one.
You need to allow yourself time, ask challenging questions and return again and again. Whether you end up with a big provider, a little local home or a place like Finlay Regional Care, the best place will be where you are treated with genuine kindness.
First, identify three possible homes this week and book your first appointments. Your future self and partner will thank you.







